In the December issue of Performer Magazine—Southeast version—writer John Barret reviews The Incredible Sandwich.

He points out the musical skill and talent of the members, especially Matt (guitarist/singer) whom he has this to say about:

Matt [...] snakes in and out of lithe, cascading solos and suave , syncopated rhythms.

He considers the 10-minute-plus song “It’s Gone” to be the album’s centerpiece cycling, “through everything from turbulent chromatic passages, to ambient drones, to heavy, gut-pommeling breakdowns to wide, open, sunlit solos”.

He does also point out Matt’s voice as the one weakness of the Sandwich’s EP.

Despite this, in The Red & Black (UGA’s student newspaper) he awards the band the title of “Best New Local Band” for this year.